I had thought a HD spring might not be a great idea. The motor's pretty much stock, just has an RV cam in it.
I took the adapter off tonight, and sure enough the piston was stuck closed. This had happened before, and I had chamfered the edges and reinstalled it. Tonight I took it out, polished it up with some 600 grit using the poor man's milling machine. I did the same to the tube in the adapter plate as well, and now the piston moves in and out very smoothly. The motor started up and there's a few new moans and groans, but it kept pressure at around 60 psi. As long as it gets me through til warm weather I'll be happy. It did seem to spit out some water drops with black oily flecks from the exhaust pipes.
As for replacing the motor, is there a good rebuilder that would be preferable to order from? The motor I have now came from www.precisionmasterengines.com but it looks like they've closed their doors. I'll also be reading up on the forum for the oiling mods and such, and looking over the great upgrade parts here to see what I'll put on the new motor when the time comes. Any suggestions on how to set up the new motor? My CJ's primarily used on the trails for rock crawling in the Rocky Mountains up here.
Thanks again for the great info. I wish I had found this place earlier.